测绘通报 ›› 2017, Vol. 0 ›› Issue (12): 48-52.doi: 10.13474/j.cnki.11-2246.2017.0377

• 学术研究 • 上一篇    下一篇

遥感影像变化检测方法的比较——以堰塞湖灾害点为例

汤志鹏1, 方国东2   

  1. 1. 北京师范大学地理科学学部, 北京 100875;
    2. 中国矿业大学机电工程学院, 江苏 徐州 221116
  • 收稿日期:2017-03-20 修回日期:2017-05-23 出版日期:2017-12-25 发布日期:2018-01-05
  • 作者简介:汤志鹏(1991-),男,硕士,主要从事遥感影像分类和变化检测算法研究。E-mail:tzp@mail.bnu.edu.cn
  • 基金资助:
    国家自然科学基金面上项目(41571334)

Comparison of Change Detection Methods for Remote Sensing Imageries: Take Yanse Lake Disaster Area as an Example

TANG Zhipeng1, FANG Guodong2   

  1. 1. Faulty of Geographical Science, Beijing Normal University, Beijing 100875, China;
    2. School of Mechatronic Engineering, China University of Mining and Technology, Xuzhou 221116, China
  • Received:2017-03-20 Revised:2017-05-23 Online:2017-12-25 Published:2018-01-05

摘要: 一个对象(现象)在不同的时间发生的变化存在着一定的相关性,利用光谱和空间相关性信息提取出地物发生变化的方法──基于邻域相关性图(NCIs)和基于交互相关性分析(CCA)的变化检测方法分别取得了不错的效果。为了探究这两种方法在土地覆盖变化检测中的适用性,对其进行应用并评价。以堰塞湖灾害点为试验区,选取了同一年份的两期高分一号卫星影像,对比了监督的基于NCIs的方法和监督的分类后比较法及非监督的基于CCA的方法和非监督的分类后比较法。结果表明:基于NCIs的方法在邻域半径等于3像素时,总体精度最大,为93.05%,比监督的分类后比较法(采用支持向量机分类器,总体精度为93.03%)稍好,但其受邻域半径的制约较大;基于CCA的方法在阈值等于20像素时,总体精度最高,为93.95%,比非监督的分类后比较法(采用ISODATA分类器,总体精度为90.52%)好,但不足在于需要经验判断并试验求取最佳阈值,以及需要已知前一个时相的地表真实值。

关键词: 遥感影像, 变化检测, 邻域相关性图, 交互相关性

Abstract: A certain correlation exists between the changes of an object (phenomenon) at different time,which can be used as one of the important features to detect changes. Many traditional change detection methods like layer arithmetic,change vector analysis,and multi-data direct comparison take no consideration of context information and spectral and spatial correlation. Neighborhood correlation images (NCIs) and cross correlation analysis (CCA) change detection methods that use spectral and spatial correlation information to extract changes in land-use both have been verified to have a good accuracy. In this paper,these two methods are applied and evaluated in order to verify their applicability. Dual phase images from GF-1 satellite of yanse lake disaster areas are chosen to conduct the experiments,where the supervised NCIs and the supervised post-classification comparison (PCC) based on support vector machine (SVM) and maximum likelihood,and the unsupervised CCA and the unsupervised PCC based on ISODATA have been compared. The results indicate that the supervised NCIs method shows the highest overall accuracy with a 3-pixel radius of neighborhood,93.05%,and it is a little higher than the supervised PCC method based on SVM whose overall accuracy is 90.52%. The demerit of the NCIs method is the constraint of neighborhood size. Moreover,the unsupervised CCA method performs best with a threshold of 20 pixels,where the overall accuracy is 93.95%. It shows more advantages than the unsupervised PCC method based on ISODATA,the overall accuracy of which is 90.52%.However,it is not easy for the CCA method to choose the proper threshold and obtain the ground-truth of a single phase image.

Key words: remote sensing imagery, change detection, neighborhood correlation images, cross correlation analysis

中图分类号: